| All-Time CoSIDA Division III Academic All-America Selections: | |||
| Year | Player | Team | Position |
| 1977-1978 | Tim Loar | First Team | Outfield |
| 1984-1985 | Andy Weyrich | Honorable Mention | First Base |
| Jim Stefanik | Honorable Mention | Outfield | |
| 1986-1987 | Erik Young | First Team | Outfield |
| Joe Velky | Second Team | Third Base | |
| Bob Rodriguez | Second Team | Designated Hitter | |
| 1988-1989 | Guy Fisher | Second Team | Second Base |
| 1997-1998 | Brian Rudloff | Honorable Mention | Pitcher |
| 2004-2005 | Mike Turchan | Second Team | Designated Hitter |
| 2007-2008 | Cody Kidd | Third Team | Outfield |
| 2008-2009 | Cody Kidd | First Team | Outfield |
| 2011-2012 | Brendan Toughey | First-Team | Outfield |
| 2012-2013 | Brendan Toughey * | First-Team | Outfield |
| 2013-2014 | Brad Gugliotta | Third Team | Third Base |
| 2016-2017 | Spencer Badia | Second-Team | Second Base |
| 2017-2018 | Spencer Badia * | First-Team | Second Base |
| 2018-2019 | Danny Cody | Third-Team | Pitcher |
| 2021-2022 | Luke Vonderhaar | Second-Team | Infielder |
| 2022-2023 | Luke Vonderhaar | First-Team | Infielder |
| All-Time Rawlings/ ABCA Coaches or D3baseball.com or Collegiate Baseball All-America Selections | |||
| 1970-1971 | Dale Herbert | First Team | First Baseman |
| 1981-1982 | Tom Bilski | Third Team | Designated Hitter |
| 2012-2013 | Brendan Toughey * | Honorable Mention (D3baseball.com) | Outfielder |
| 2013-2014 | Brian Harrison (Head Coach) | Rawlings/ ABCA Mideast Region | Coach of the Year |
| 2013-2014 | Kyle Chontos | Second-Team (Rawlings/ ABCA) | First Base |
| Kyle Chontos | Honorable Mention (D3baseball.com) | First Base | |
| 2015-2016 | Mark Zimmerman | First-Team (Rawlings/ ABCA) | Pitcher/ Infielder |
| 2017-2018 | Dudley Taw | Second-Team (Rawlings/ ABCA | Outfielder |
| 2018-2019 | Danny Cody | Second-Team (Rawlings/ ABCA | Pitcher |
| Danny Cody | Fourth-Team (D3baseball.com) | Pitcher | |
| 2021-2022 | Luke Vonderhaar | Third-Team (D3baseball.com) | Infielder |
| Luke Vonderhaar | Fourth-Team (ABCA/Rawlings) | Infielder | |
| 2022-2023 | Alexis Castillo | Fourth-Team (ABCA/Rawlings) | First Base |
| Alexis Castillo | Fourth-Team (ABCA/Rawlings) | First Base | |