|
Year |
Player | Position | Team |
| 1970-1971 | Dale Herbert | First Base | First-Team |
| 1972-1973 | Dale Herbert | First Base | First-Team |
| 1981-1982 | Tom Bilski | Designated Hitter | First Team |
| 1982-1983 | Jeff Andrews | First Base | Second Team |
| 1983-1984 | Tom Bilski | Designated Hitter | First Team |
| Jim Magazine | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| 1984-1985 | Jim Stefanik | Outfield | First Team |
| Jim Magazine | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| 1985-1986 | Dean Obrock | Pitcher | Second Team |
| Erik Young | Outfield | Second Team | |
| Jim Magazine | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| 1986-1987 | Erik Young | Outfield | First Team |
| 1987-1988 | Erik Young | Outfield | First Team |
| Bernie Bonhotel | Pitcher | Honorable Mention | |
| Paul Farrah | Designated Hitter | Honorable Mention | |
| 1988-1989 | Erik Young | Outfield | Second Team |
| Phil Stringer | Outfield | Honorable Mention | |
| 1999-1990 | Phil Stringer | Designated Hitter | First Team |
| Brian Kosar | Pitcher | Second Team | |
| Dan DeVoe | Third Base | Second Team | |
| Andy Palmer | First Base | Honorable Mention | |
| Bryan Dudash | Outfield | Honorable Mention | |
| 1990-1991 | Joey Dallas | Catcher | Second Team |
| Bob Kelley | Designated Hitter | Honorable Mention | |
| 1991-1002 | Joey Dallas | Catcher | Second Team |
| Dave Snyder | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| Mark Massey | Outfield | Honorable Mention | |
| 1992-1993 | Phil Lopez | Catcher | Honorable Mention |
| Greg Andrego | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| 1993-1994 | Phil Lopez | Catcher | Honorable Mention |
| 1994-1995 | Joel Nichols | Catcher | Second Team |
| 1995-1996 | Joel Nichols | Catcher | Second Team |
| Steve Murphy | Second Base | Honorable Mention | |
| 1997-1998 | Brian Rudloff | Pitcher | Second Team |
| 2000-2001 | Jim Leffler | Shortstop | First Team |
| 2001-2002 | Pat Shannon | First Base | Second Team |
| Jim Leffler | Shortstop | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) | |
| Pete Rowe | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (Honorable Mention) | |
| 2002-2003 | Pat Shannon | First Base | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) |
| Jim Leffler | Shortstop | Rawlings/ ABCA (Honorable Mention) | |
| 2003-2004 | Mike Farrell | Designated Hitter | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) |
| Dale Koler | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (Third Team) | |
| Mike Turchan | Utility Player | Rawlings/ ABCA (Third Team) | |
| 2008-2009 | Cody Kidd | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) |
| Riley Kreisher | First Base | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) | |
| 2011-2012 | Jon Tenley | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) |
| Brendan Toughey | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (Third Team) | |
| 2012-2013 | Brendan Toughey | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (First Team) |
| Brenda Toughey | Outfield | D3baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| 2013-2014 | Kyle Chontos | First Base | Rawlings/ ABCA (First-Team) |
| Kyle Chontos | First Base | D3baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| Mark Zimmerman | Second Base | D3baseball.com (Second Team) | |
| Mark Zimmerman | Utility Pitcher 2B | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second-Team) | |
| Hunter Handel | Designated Hitter | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second Team) | |
| D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |||
| Cory Waite | Pitcher | D3baseball.com (Honorable Mention) | |
| 2014-2015 | Mark Zimmerman | Pitcher/ Utility Player | Rawlings/ ABCA (First-Team) |
| Mark Zimmerman | Pitcher/ Utility Player | D3baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| Cole Nieto | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second-Team) | |
| Cole Nieto | Outfield | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Hunter Handel | First Base | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| 2015-2016 | Mark Zimmerman # | Pitcher/ Utility | Rawlings/ ABCA (First-Team) |
| Mark Zimmerman # | Pitcher/ Utility | D3baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| Evan Lovick | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second-Team) | |
| Evan Lovick | Pitcher | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| 2016-2017 | Evan Lovick | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second-Team) |
| Evan Lovick | Pitcher | D3baseball.com (Second-team) | |
| Cole Nieto | Second Base | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| 2017-2018 | Dudley Taw # | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (First-Team) |
| Dudley Taw | Outfield | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Alex Marcum | Outfield | Rawlings/ ABCA (Second-Team) | |
| Alex Marcum | Outfield | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Evan Lovick | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (Third-Team) | |
| Evan Lovick | Pitcher | D3baseball.com (Third-team) | |
| Danny Cody | Pitcher | ABCA (Third-Team) | |
| 2018-2019 | Danny Cody # | Pitcher | Rawlings/ ABCA (First-Team) |
| Danny Cody # | Pitcher | D3Baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| 2020-2021 | Alex Ludwick | Infielder | D3baseball.com (First-Team) |
| Alex Ludwick | Infielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Second-Team) | |
| Dudley Taw | Outfielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Second-Team) | |
| 2021-2022 | Luke Vonderhaar | Infielder | ABCA/Rawlings (First-Team) |
| Luke Vonderhaar | Infielder | D3baseball.com (First-Team) | |
| Alex Ludwick | Infielder | ABCA/Rawlings (First-Team) | |
| Alex Ludwick | Infielder | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Vincent Capolupo | Outfielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Second-Team) | |
| Vincent Capolupo | Outfielder | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Drew Wilson | Outfielder/Pitcher | ABCA/Rawlings (Third-Team) | |
| 2022-2023 | Alexis Castillo | First Base | ABCA/Rawlings (First-Team) |
| Alexis Castillo | First Base | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Garrett Miller | Pitcher | ABCA/Rawlings (Second-Team) | |
| Garrett Miller | Pitcher | D3baseball.com (Second-Team) | |
| Sean Kolenich | Infielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Second-Team) | |
| Vincent Capolupo | Outfielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Third-Team) | |
| Luke Vonderhaar | Infielder | ABCA/Rawlings (Third-Team) |