The Baldwin Wallace football prgram has had a total of 162 All-Americans. The complete list of football players, years, and sponsor is listed below
| Name | Team | Year |
| Paul Lisse | Small College | 1926 |
| Clarence Wing | Small College | 1932 |
| Norm Schoen | Small College | 1937 |
| Jim Tyree | Small College | 1954 |
| Obie Bender | Methodist Small College | 1962 |
| Tom Goosby | Methodist Small College | 1962 |
| John Halter | Methodist Small College | 1962 |
| Obie Bender | NAIA Small College | 1962 |
| Tom Goosby | NAIA Small College | 1962 |
| Tom Goosby | Methodist Small College | 1963 |
| Larry Shinn | Methodist Small College | 1963 |
| Bob Quackenbush | NAIA Small College | 1968 |
| Vern Shaubaugh | NAIA Small College | 1968 |
| Tom Graham | American Football Coaches Association | 1971 |
| Mark Summers | Associated Press Little | 1974 |
| Roger Andrachik | American Football Coaches Association | 1978 |
| Paul Petrella | American Football Coaches Association | 1978 |
| Jeff Jenkins | American Football Coaches Association | 1978 |
| Paul Petrella | Associated Press Little | 1978 |
| Jeff Jenkins | Associated Press Little | 1978 |
| Fred Buchanan | Associated Press Little | 1978 |
| Tom Kelsey | Associated Press Little | 1979 |
| Dan Delfino | Associated Press Little | 1980 |
| Chuck Krajcic | American Football Coaches Association | 1981 |
| Pete Primeau | American Football Coaches Association | 1981 |
| Pete Primeau | American Football Coaches Association | 1982 |
| Steve Varga | American Football Coaches Association | 1982 |
| Jeff Rutherford | Pizza Hut | 1983 |
| Steve Varga | American Football Coaches Association | 1983 |
| Rick Newsock | Football News | 1984 |
| Kert Boedicker | Pizza Hut | 1984 |
| David Miller | Pizza Hut | 1984 |
| Brian Moore | Pizza Hut | 1984 |
| Kert Boedicker | Football News | 1985 |
| Kert Boedicker | Pizza Hut | 1985 |
| David Miller | Pizza Hut | 1985 |
| John Price | Pizza Hut | 1985 |
| Mark Schwertner | Pizza Hut | 1985 |
| Phil Trupo | Pizza Hut | 1985 |
| Shawn Gorman | Associated Press Little | 1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller | Associated Press Little | 1986 |
| Jeff Welcsh | Associated Press Little | 1986 |
| Shawn Gorman | Football News | 1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller | Football News | 1986 |
| Jeff Welcsh | Football News | 1986 |
| Shawn Gorman | Pizza Hut | 1986 |
| Chris Riemenschneider | Pizza Hut | 1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller | Pizza Hut | 1986 |
| Lorne Conyers | Associated Press Little | 1987 |
| Shawn Gorman | Associated Press Little | 1987 |
| Greg Profancik | Associated Press Little | 1987 |
| Dirk Riemenschneider | Associated Press Little | 1987 |
| Jerry Sponseller | Associated Press Little | 1987 |
| Lorne Conyers | Football News | 1987 |
| Shawn Gorman | Football News | 1987 |
| Wade Massad | Football News | 1987 |
| Greg Profancik | Football News | 1987 |
| Dirk Riemenschneider | Football News | 1987 |
| Lorne Conyers | Pizza Hut | 1987 |
| Shawn Gorman | Pizza Hut | 1987 |
| Greg Profancik | Pizza Hut | 1987 |
| Doug Haubert | Associated Press Little | 1988 |
| Matt Kubinski | Associated Press Little | 1988 |
| Wade Massad | Associated Press Little | 1988 |
| Phil Medvetz | Associated Press Little | 1988 |
| Scott Wilson | Associated Press Little | 1988 |
| Shawn Gorman | Football News | 1988 |
| Matt Kubinski | Football News | 1988 |
| Wade Massad | Football News | 1988 |
| Phil Medvetz | Football News | 1988 |
| Erik Young | Football News | 1988 |
| Doug Haubert | Pizza Hut | 1988 |
| Wade Massad | Pizza Hut | 1988 |
| Phil Medvetz | Pizza Hut | 1988 |
| Scott Wilson | Pizza Hut | 1988 |
| Doug Haubert | American Football Coaches Association | 1989 |
| Doug Haubert | Associated Press Little | 1989 |
| Dan Andrews | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1989 |
| Chuck Geiss | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1989 |
| Doug Haubert | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1989 |
| Phil Medvetz | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1989 |
| Dan Andrews | Pizza Hut | 1989 |
| Doug Haubert | Pizza Hut | 1989 |
| Phil Medvetz | Pizza Hut | 1989 |
| Mike Laubacher | Associated Press Little | 1990 |
| Mike Laubacher | Champion-USA | 1990 |
| Mike Rodak | Champion-USA | 1990 |
| Colin Johnson | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1990 |
| Mike Laubacher | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1990 |
| Mike Rodak | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1990 |
| Bob Anderson | Champion-USA | 1991 |
| Jim Clardy | Champion-USA | 1991 |
| Mike Barbetta | Champion-USA | 1991 |
| John Koz | Champion-USA | 1991 |
| Tom Serdinak | Champion-USA | 1991 |
| Mike Barbetta | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1991 |
| Jim Clardy | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1991 |
| John Koz | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1991 |
| Jim Clardy | Champion-USA | 1992 |
| Tom Garfield | Champion-USA | 1992 |
| John Koz | Champion-USA | 1992 |
| Jim Clardy | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| Tom Garfield | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| John Koz | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| Gus Patouhas | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| Kevin Stedman | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| Lance Yandell | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1992 |
| Bill Linder | Champion-USA | 1993 |
| Scott Hershiser | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1993 |
| John Koz | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1993 |
| Bill Linder | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1993 |
| Phil Sahley | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1993 |
| Lance Yandell | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1993 |
| Chris Kondik | Associated Press Little | 1994 |
| Phil Sahley | Associated Press Little | 1994 |
| Jason Klein | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1994 |
| Chris Kondik | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1994 |
| Phil Sahley | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1994 |
| Chris Kondik | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 1994 |
| Tony Oden | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 1994 |
| Phil Sahley | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 1994 |
| Phil Sahley | Schooner's Coaches Association | 1994 |
| Fred Saylor | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1996 |
| Fred Saylor | Hewlett-Packard | 1996 |
| Chris Kondik | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1997 |
| Fred Saylor | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 1997 |
| Chris Kondik | Hewlett-Packard | 1997 |
| Fred Saylor | Hewlett-Packard | 1997 |
| Mike Blackburn | Hewlett-Packard | 1998 |
| Joe Dobies | Hewlett-Packard | 2000 |
| Matt Caine | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2001 |
| Greg Koch | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2002 |
| Greg Koch | Hewlett-Packard | 2002 |
| Greg Koch | American Football Coaches Association | 2003 |
| Mark Anders | D3football.com | 2003 |
| Greg Koch | D3football.com | 2003 |
| Nate Mitchell | D3football.com | 2003 |
| Nate Wilder | D3football.com | 2003 |
| Mark Anders | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 2003 |
| Ian Formaz | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 2003 |
| Nate Mitchell | NCAA Division III Sports Information Directors | 2003 |
| Mark Anders | Associated Press Little | 2004 |
| Ian Formaz | Associated Press Little | 2004 |
| Greg Koch | Associated Press Little | 2004 |
| Nate Mitchell | Associated Press Little | 2004 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | D3football.com | 2004 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2004 |
| Ryan Lewis | D3football.com | 2005 |
| Joe George | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2005 |
| Ryan Lewis | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2005 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | Associated Press Little | 2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | D3football.com | 2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | D3football.com | 2007 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | Don Hansen's Football Gazette | 2007 |
| Matt Harmon | American Football Coaches Association | 2013 |
| Jason Cook | D3football.com | 2013 |
| Matt Harmon | D3football.com | 2013 |
| Patrick Simon | American Football Coaches Association | 2021 (Fall) |
| Nick Pankow | D3football.com | 2021 (Fall) |
| Patrick Simon | D3football.com | 2021 (Fall) |
| Anthony Kendall | American Football Coaches Association | 2022 |
| Anthony Kendall | Associated Press | 2022 |
| Anthony Kendall | D3football.com | 2022 |