| # | NAME | YEARS | RECORD | .PCT |
| 1. | Stanley Bleich | 2017-22 | 136-29 | .824 |
| 2. | Garrett Chase | 2012-16 | 129-37 | .777 |
| 3. | Jesse Gunter | 2012-16 | 122-16 | .884 |
| 4. | Anthony Arroyo | 2015-19 | 120-21 | .851 |
| Zeckary Lehman | 2015-20 | 120-29 | .805 | |
| 6. | Doug Byrne | 2019-2024 | 117-20 | .854 |
| 7. | Michael Petrella | 2021-Present | 115-4 | .966 |
| 8. | Charlie Nash | 2016-20 | 112-44 | 718 |
| 9. | Mark Tinney | 1993-97 | 111-32 | .776 |
| 10. | Tony Cipollone | 1988-93 | 110-25-1 | .813 |
| David Shapiro | 2012-17 | 110-40 | .733 | |
| 12. | Dalton Leightner | 2017-22 | 105-44 | .705 |
| 13. | Jaden Hinton | 2021-Present | 104-18 | .852 |
| 14. | Kevin Higgins | 1985-89 | 100-27-1 | .785 |
| 15. | Bobby Bollas | 1994-98 | 98-52 | .653 |
| 16. | Chris Doyle | 2014-18 | 97-53 | .647 |
| 17. | Tyler Maclellan | 2014-18 | 96-48 | .667 |
| 18. | Kevin Atkins | 1997-2000 | 95-24 | .798 |
| Ben Lebrun | 2012-16 | 95-60 | .613 | |
| 20. | Doug Knight | 1991-95 | 94-54 | .635 |
| 21. | Gino Russo | 2004-08 | 92-29 | .760 |
| Andrew Taylor | 2010-14 | 92-70 | .568 | |
| 23. | Jacob Decatur | 2022-Present | 90-7 | .928 |
| Bryan Kmetz | 2003-07 | 90-14 | .865 | |
| 25. | Dante Ginnetti | 2016-21 | 89-32 | .736 |
| 26. | Joey Schmidt | 2012-16 | 87-56 | .608 |
| 27. | Andrew Scavuzzo | 2007-11 | 86-34 | .717 |
| 28. | Brian Bucher | 2005-09 | 83-35 | .703 |
| 29. | Tanner McHugh | 2017-22 | 83-39 | .680 |
| Tommy West | 2022-Present | 83-31 | .728 | |
| 31. | Graham Montague | 2013-17 | 80-58 | .580 |
| 32. | Gabe Mahaney | 2014-18 | 78-33 | .703 |
| 33. | Hunter Kupniewski | 2021-2024 | 77-40 | .658 |
| Benjamin Hooff | 2015-20 | 77-44 | .836 | |
| Dan Hulten | 1988-92 | 77-51 | .602 | |
| 36. | Joe Heiland | 2000-05 | 76-25 | .752 |
| 37. | Mike Blackburn | 1995-99 | 75-50 | .600 |
| Tony Marcellino | 1996-2000 | 75-55 | .577 | |
| 39. | Robby Palmieri | 2021-2024 | 74-37 | .667 |
| 40. | Kelly Keenan | 1990-94 | 73-13 | .849 |
| Justin Ransom | 2016-19 | 73-28 | .723 | |
| Mike Durkalec | 1989-93 | 73-30 | .709 | |
| 43. | Richie Burke | 2015-19 | 72-38 | .655 |
| Carter Lloyd | 2021-Present | 72-31 | .699 | |
| 45. | Devin Carman | 2002-06 | 71-15 | .826 |
| Joe Belford | 2012-16 | 71-55 | .563 | |
| 47. | Paul Petrella | 1975-79 | 68-12 | .850 |
| 48. | Jared Selover | 2002-07 | 67-20 | .770 |
| 49. | Sterling Sebek | 2001-06 | 65-45 | .591 |